Personal Loans vs Student Loans: 2026 Comparison Guide
Manage Your Money
Compare personal loans and credit for student loans. Discover rates, terms, and which option fits your goals. Get expert guidance from Broadview.
Picking the right loan for the right purpose matters more than most people realize. Student loans are built specifically for education—tuition, books, housing. Personal loans work for nearly anything else. The trick? Understanding how they differ may save you money and keep your options open when life throws you a curveball.
Table of Contents
We've seen members use personal loans to consolidate debt, cover moving costs, or handle unexpected expenses. Student loans, on the other hand, come with features designed for people navigating school—like grace periods after graduation and income-based payment plans. At Broadview, we think clarity around these differences helps you move forward with confidence.
How These Loans Actually Work
The big difference comes down to purpose, cost, and timing. Federal student loans typically carry interest rates between 5% and 8%, set by Congress each July. Personal loan rates usually land somewhere between 8% and 15%—or higher if your credit needs work. That gap compounds over time.
Repayment structure matters, too. Federal student loans don't require payments while you're in school, and you may qualify for income-driven plans once you graduate. Personal loans? Payments usually start within 30 days, and they're fixed for the life of the loan—typically two to seven years.
| Feature | Student Loans | Personal Loans |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use | Tuition, fees, books, housing | Any legal purpose |
| Interest Rates | Typically 5%–8% (federal) | Often 8%–15%+ |
| Repayment Start | After graduation (federal) | Immediately |
| Forgiveness Options | Yes (federal programs) | No |
If you're weighing your options, start by asking what you're buying. Education costs belong with student loans. Everything else? That's where personal loans shine.
Why Personal Loans Don't Make Sense for Tuition
When the tuition bill arrives and federal aid doesn't cover it all, a personal loan might seem like the fastest fix. In reality, you're trading speed for flexibility—and paying more for it.
Here's what you lose. Federal student loans include protections that personal loans don't offer:
- Grace periods: No payments required while you're enrolled in school at least half-time
- Income-driven repayment: Your payment may change based on your actual earnings
- Deferment and forbearance: Options to pause payments during financial hardship
- Public Service Loan Forgiveness: Potential balance reduction after 120 qualifying payments in certain careers
Personal loans lock you into a fixed monthly payment regardless of your situation. Lost your job? Payment stays the same. Salary lower than expected? Payment doesn't budge.
Real Talk: Federal student loans are almost always your best bet for education costs. They're cheaper, more flexible, and built for students—not general borrowers.
Private student loans can fill the gap when federal loans aren't enough. Many private lenders offer in-school deferment, co-signer release after a set number of on-time payments, and terms designed around graduation timelines. Learn more about student loan options before committing to a personal loan for school.
When You Actually Need a Personal Loan
Personal loans work best for non-education expenses with clear end dates. Consolidating credit card debt? That's a textbook use case. If you're carrying balances across multiple cards at 18% to 24% interest, rolling them into a single personal loan at 10% may cut your monthly payment and total interest. Just don't run up new card balances while paying off the loan.
Here's what else fits:
- Relocation costs: Security deposits, moving trucks, travel for a new job
- Professional development: Licensing fees, certification programs, equipment for self-employment
- Medical or dental bills: Procedures not covered by insurance
- Home repairs: Unexpected fixes like a broken furnace or roof leak
Quick Tip: Personal loans work for one-time costs you can repay within a few years. They're not ideal for recurring expenses or open-ended projects.
Before you apply, compare rates from at least three lenders. Watch for origination fees—some lenders charge up to 5% upfront, which increases your total cost.
At Broadview, we'll walk through the numbers with you and help you figure out what makes sense. You can also explore our Fresh Start Loan options for flexible borrowing. Want more details? Check out this overview of personal loans.
How These Loans Affect Your Credit
Both loan types report to the major credit bureaus, which means on-time payments help build your credit history. Student loans give you years to demonstrate consistency. Personal loans add another installment account to your profile, which scoring models like to see alongside credit cards.
But here's what actually matters: paying on time and keeping your debt load manageable relative to your income. Credit mix helps, but it's not the main driver of your score. Payment history is.
Set It and Forget It: Automatic payments prevent late payments, which can tank your score for up to seven years. Even one missed payment hurts.
Building good credit takes time. If you want to review how your current borrowing fits your longer-term goals, stop by a Broadview branch or give us a call. We're happy to talk through what's working and what might need adjusting.
Choosing the Right Path for You
Your decision hinges on what you're funding. Education costs? Student loans, full stop. Non-education expenses you can repay in a few years? A personal loan may make sense.
Here's the playbook we recommend:
- Complete the FAFSA and accept all grants and scholarships first
- Borrow federal student loans up to annual limits
- If you still need funds, compare private student loan options
- Use personal loans only for non-education needs
The Smart Borrowing Order: Federal student loans first. Private student loans second. Personal loans for everything else.
Not sure which path fits? We get it—borrowing decisions feel high-stakes. Broadview can help you compare costs, timelines, and repayment flexibility based on your actual situation. Learn more about federal student aid programs on the Federal Student Aid website.
What's Changing in the Next Few Years
Federal student loan programs shift with policy updates and budget cycles. Income-driven repayment plans and forgiveness programs may be revised, so it pays to check official sources periodically and adjust your plan accordingly.
Interest rates respond to broader economic conditions too. Personal loan rates typically move after Federal Reserve adjustments. Federal student loan rates for new borrowers reset each July, which can affect timing if you're planning to borrow soon.
Credit scoring models also evolve. The fundamentals don't change though—pay on time, keep debt manageable, and avoid maxing out credit lines.
Want a yearly check-in on your borrowing plan? Broadview can help you review your current loans and discuss options that may lower costs or simplify payments. Explore our Financial Well-Being Education resources for ongoing support.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is it important to choose between a personal loan and a student loan for my education?
Choosing the right loan type for education can really save you money and stress down the road. Student loans are specifically designed to cover education costs and often come with lower interest rates and flexible repayment options. Personal loans, while versatile, typically carry higher costs and fewer borrower protections.
What makes federal student loans a good choice for college expenses?
Federal student loans are often the best fit for education costs because they typically offer lower interest rates, which are set by Congress, not your credit score. They also come with flexible repayment plans, like income-driven options, and protections such as deferment during financial hardship. Some federal programs even offer potential forgiveness, which personal loans usually do not.
Besides education, what are some common situations where a personal loan can be helpful?
Personal loans can be a smart choice for goals unrelated to tuition. For example, they are great for consolidating high-interest credit card debt into a single, lower-rate payment. They can also cover one-time expenses like moving costs for a new job, unexpected medical bills, or necessary home repairs.
Can personal loans and student loans help me build my credit?
Yes, both personal loans and student loans can help you build a positive credit history. When you make your payments on time, lenders report this to credit bureaus. Consistent, on-time payments are key to showing you can manage debt responsibly, which helps improve your credit score over time.
If I need to borrow for school, what's the recommended order of loan options?
When borrowing for school, it's smart to start with federal student aid options, like grants and scholarships, first. If you still need funds, federal student loans are usually the next best step due to their benefits. Private student loans can then fill any remaining gaps before you consider personal loans.
Do personal loans typically cost more than student loans?
Generally, personal loans have higher interest rates compared to student loans, especially federal ones. Personal loan rates often range from 8% to 15% or more, depending on your credit profile. Student loans, particularly federal ones, are typically between 5% and 8% and are designed to be more affordable for education.
Last reviewed: March 1, 2026 by the Broadview Team
